Best Burgers We Ate This Year

Our Best Burgers of the Year

We ate a lot of burgers this year. Heck, it’s late in the year and we are still eating burgers. We traveled a lot too — from New Mexico to Alabama (a couple times) and from Florida to Ohio and back again. Plus, there were a ton of day trips around Alabama, Tennessee, and Mississippi. Frankly, we did so much traveling that sometimes the hope of finding the next great burger was what kept us driving. For now, we focus on best burgers New Mexico. (It’s a great state. If you haven’t been, you should get there!) 

Best Burgers of New Mexico

Papaburgers
6601 4th Street Northwest, Albuquerque, NM
— The first part of the year, we were still based in New Mexico. Now, 1,500 miles away, I still miss Papaburgers. Their burgers are the smashed kind, with that crisp caramelization you get from a flattop grill. It doesn’t hurt that onions are mixed right into the meat. Add a thick slice of New Mexico green chili and you have a mouthwatering mix of flavor, heat and heart. This strip-mall joint also has killer chile-cheese fries and flavorful hotdogs.

 best burger newmexico. green chile cheese burger, Albuquerque, New Mexico
Fresh ground Papaburger with green chile and Am. cheese

Sugar’s BBQ and Hamburgers
1799 New Mexico 68, Velarde, NM 87582
— Sometimes it’s more than the meat that makes a great burger. Sugar’s has a fresh, drippy, good burger, but add in a laid-back scene and scenic out-of-the-way location. We spent one long, lazy afternoon sitting at one of the outside tables (it’s a walk-up place) enjoying an almost perfect burger experience. Sugar’s is one of those hole-in-the-places that the locals know about. Hours vary at this seasonal biz, so call ahead (505-852-0604). Read more about Sugar’s on Trip Advisor.

sugarbearburger
Sugar Bear Burger, Sugar’s BBQ and Burgers, New Mexico

Santa Fe Bite (formerly Bob Cat Bite)
311 Old Santa Fe Trail – Santa Fe NM 87501
— We must mention Santa Fe Bite. Before this little burger joint grew up, changed it’s name and moved to town, it consistently made “best of” burger lists across the nation, and with good reason. While we could wax poetic and claim we were eating at “Bobcat” Bite before it had a porch or a paved(!) lot, we will just say the burger is still a hunk of juicy awesomeness. It stays the Best of the Best Burger List. Go to Santa Fe and eat a burger at Santa Bite. Until then, read an interview with Santa Fe Bite owner, John Eckre, at Serious Eats.

Santa Fe Bite, best Burger New Mexico 2014
Best of the best burgers –Santa Fe Bite/ Photo – Santa Fe Bite, via Serious Eats

More Burgers of Note in NM

Holy Cow,
700 Central Avenue SE, Albuquerque
— Thick, well-flavored upscale burgers, an amazing veggie sandwich and thick, rich shakes that are a meals on their own. Skip the sweet potato fries, and try the zucchini fries instead. (Sides are enough to share). Holy Cow provides a satisfying experience for burger lovers and their gluten-free and veggie friends too.

Holy Cow! Burger best burger Albuquerque
Holy Cow! Burger with goat cheese, roasted peppers and basil.

Laguna Burger
(West Albuquerque) — Basic burgers done right. Fresh and hot, Add green chile! Heading down I-40, there is one inside the Pit Stop 66 gas station, in each direction. DO NOT reply on your GPS to find these. Just keep your eyes peeled for the signs. Said a local food writer, the Laguna Burger is a “half-pound of pure deliciousness.”

Luguna Burger, inside Pit Stop 66
Luguna Burger, inside Pit Stop 66

Effing Bar
5300 Sequoia Road, Albuquerque, NM 8712
— Yep, a true neighborhood bar with one of the most under-rated burgers in Albuquerque. Nothing fancy, but, juicy and full of flavor, served with fries or onion rings. Either are a good choice. It’s a bar, so don’t expect ambiance. However, the friendly locals and great staff make it a fun experience.

effingbar albuquerque
Neighborhood bar burger with green chile and cheese /Photo – Effing Bar

 Stay tuned and follow us on Facebook.

Denise Shalifoe

Looking forward to trying burgers at the Effing Bar, Laguna Burger, and Holy Cow. We drive by all of these places a lot. We’ve had Papa Burgers. They were pretty tasty.

If you are ever up Omaha way, check out King Kong’s on south 72nd St. The burgers and fries are great and the gyro salad is fabulous! Firebirds out on West Dodge Rd. has great burgers, too.

Bob Curmudgeon

Your NM list is ‘right-on’.
Once worked at A-Frame places in SoCal called Woody’s Smorgaburgers. Its uniqueness was serving burgers on a Kaiser Roll whereby you added your own condiments from a separate setup. The Favs were Thousand Island (“new” back in the ’50-’80s) and chopped nuts from the DIY sundae bar. Oooh that it would have had NM roasted/chopped Green Chile back in those days!

Bob

Next time you are in Albuquerque, try The Ranchero Supreme at one of Bob’s Burgers (several locations). While I prefer diced green chile on most GCCB, every couple of months there is something about this sloppy green sauce concoction that calls me back.

Also, I think Casa de Benavidez is the only place that has successfully served a Green Chile Sopapilla Burger over many years. (Speaking of sopapillas tho and if truth be told…ya gotta try the Stuffed Sopapilla with chicharrones and beans with Red and extra onions.)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *